Start with the balls covered
Write down the work you intend to buy before comparing totals. A line for a complete set might cover every ball, while another offer might include inspection of the set and restoration of selected balls. Ask both businesses to record which balls they will restore and which they will only inspect. Confirm whether they charge for inspection, and whether the cue ball is included. Two offers for the same number of balls can include different amounts of work.
Read the line describing the finish
A quote that mentions loss of gloss may leave the treatment of a distinct scratch open. Mark the areas that matter to you and ask whether the quoted work covers those marks as well as the overall finish. If the supplier needs to see the ball first, ask for that decision to be marked as pending. Agree how you will approve any extra work and cost before it starts, and keep the agreed description with both offers.
Separate the service fee from transport
Check who pays for sending the balls, return carriage and any packing or handling charge. A return-inclusive total and a service-only price are on different bases until both use the same destination and parcel count. Record the currency. For a club sending several batches, ask whether carriage applies per parcel or per shipment. Mark unconfirmed charges as pending so that an empty cell is never counted as zero.
Compare a single pair of offers
Suppose your cue ball and seven ball need restoration and you want the rest of the set inspected. Make a table with one column per quote and four rows for the two restorations, the inspection of the remaining balls and return carriage. For each row write included, extra or pending. If one supplier priced all the balls for restoration, ask for a revised total on the four-row brief. Compare the totals and expected return dates only after the entries match.
| Item to confirm | Quote A | Quote B |
|---|---|---|
| Restoring the cue ball | Included | Included |
| Treating the scratch on No. 7 | Included | Pending inspection |
| Inspection of the other balls | Extra charge | Included |
| Return shipping | Included | To be confirmed |